I've been trying to follow this Welfare Reform Issue. I'm still not sure I totally understand both because it's kind of complicated and neither side has really comprehensively explained what's happening. This is what I believe: Utah and Nevada want the Federal Government to relax some of the work requirements included in Welfare Reform. These are the provisions that ensure that people who receive welfare are not just lying about watching TV. They say, not that they want to allow this kind of sloth, but they want to be able to have their own definitions of work (like going to school). The Obama administration replied it was willing to consider granting waivers if more information is given.
Cynical conservatives believe the Obama Administration is doing this to weaken the work requirements, while the Obama Administration claims it is trying to provide more flexibility but maintain the spirit of the law.
I guess only time will tell who is correct, but this story has two passages I find extremely interesting.
The first is a quote from George Sheldon, acting Assistant Secretary for the Administration for Children and Families at HHS. "Federal rules dictate mind-numbing details about how to run a welfare-to-work program. Many states report that their caseworkers are spending more time complying with federal-documentation requirements than helping parents find jobs."
Have you ever heard a Democrat decry a regulatory burden. When Republicans complain about too many regulations choking the economy, generally, there's no response from Democrats. Probably because Democrats believe in regulations but they poll poorly. Maybe Democrats have decided regulations that restrain the private economy are good, but regulations that restrain the public sector are bad.
The article's authors, Louise Radnofsky and Janet Hook say "The outcry was a shift for Republicans, who have traditionally pushed for states to have greater control over how they spend federal dollars. The Obama administration has tried to portray many of its policies as giving states more latitude."
This is very interesting. I county myself as someone who "traditionally pushes for states to have greater control over how they spend federal dollars." How can I reconcile this seeming discrepancy?
If I'm pro-federalism (which I am), and anti state to state redistribution of taxes (which I am), then how can I disagree with these waivers? Well, if the Obama administration is sincere in wanting to relax the specific requirements but maintain the general work requirement, then I completely agree with what they're doing. Conservatives are worried that they are just using this as an excuse to increase the size of the program by increasing aid to those who don't work.
Monday, July 16, 2012
A Rambling, Incoherent Mess
I don't know if this speech was pre-written and read from a teleprompter or if President's Obama's remarks are extemporaneous. What I do know is that this argument is poorly constructed.
It has three paragraphs; here's an outline of the argument.
In subsequent posts, I want to dissect this argument point by point.
It has three paragraphs; here's an outline of the argument.
- People aren't successful because they're smart.
- People aren't successful because they work hard.
- Successful people interacted with other people on the way to success.
- Successful people used communal infrastructure on the way to success.
- Example: The government created the internet.
- Successful people are successful because they have individual initiative and they work together.
- Example: Fire fighters work together.
In subsequent posts, I want to dissect this argument point by point.
Tuesday, July 3, 2012
What's Good Enough for Them
In Friday's edition of Left, Right, and Center, the representative for the Left, Robert Scheer was asked whether Obama or Romney was helped by the Supreme Court decision. Robert Scheer's response (presented as a question directed to Romney by Obama)
The answer is that the people in Massachusetts aren't necessarily representative of the people in the rest of the country. Whatever is the best solution for Massachusetts may not be the best solution for the nation as a whole. That's why people like me are strong advocates of federalism. Letting each state find its own solution. A national solution for a problem as complex as health care will never be as optimal as different solutions tailored to different populations of the country.
(starting at 16:30) What you did for Massachusetts I did for the rest of the country. How could you disagree with that? How can you call that socialized medicine? How can you say that's an unfair intrusion into people's lives? If it was good enough for the people of Massachusetts, why is it not good enough for the rest of the country? And I've extended it to 30 million people. I think that's an argument Romney loses. I don't even know what the answer is.The Right's representative, John Eastman, gave a political answer: it raised taxes, it takes away freedom, etc. Maybe the philosophical response doesn't poll well, but I wanted to make sure that people realize that people like me have a much stronger answer to this question.
The answer is that the people in Massachusetts aren't necessarily representative of the people in the rest of the country. Whatever is the best solution for Massachusetts may not be the best solution for the nation as a whole. That's why people like me are strong advocates of federalism. Letting each state find its own solution. A national solution for a problem as complex as health care will never be as optimal as different solutions tailored to different populations of the country.
Monday, July 2, 2012
Simultaneously a Tax and Not a Tax
There are several aspects of the Supreme Court's decision on the ACA that still perplex me.
What exactly is the difference between a tax and a fine?
Don't taxes have to be paid before they can be challenged?
Don't taxes have to begin in the House of Representatives?
What is the explanation for the Medicaid decision?
I find reading the direct opinions can be very illuminating. For example, I read the Conservative bloc's opinion, and came away with the realization that really they made a very strong case that Congress believed the mandate was not a tax, but not such a strong case, that it Constitutionally wasn't a tax.
Today, I think I can answer the second question.
This issue is discussed by Chief Justice Roberts on page 11 of his opinion (17 of the pdf)
It seems the answer to why this is not a tax for the purposes of the Anti-Injunction Act but is a tax for Constitutional Purposes is that the Anti-Injunction Act was written by Congress. So it applies only to things that Congress thinks is a tax.
It would be like if you and I had different definitions for the same thing, say a computer. Then I said I will buy you a computer. Do you expect what you consider a computer, or do you expect that I give you my version of a computer.
Since Congress passed the Anti-Injunction Act, and said taxes must be paid before they can be challenged. Then they wrote the ACA which calls it a "penalty," so the Anti-Injunction Act doesn't apply to it. I'll try to think of an analogy to make this clear.
What exactly is the difference between a tax and a fine?
Don't taxes have to be paid before they can be challenged?
Don't taxes have to begin in the House of Representatives?
What is the explanation for the Medicaid decision?
I find reading the direct opinions can be very illuminating. For example, I read the Conservative bloc's opinion, and came away with the realization that really they made a very strong case that Congress believed the mandate was not a tax, but not such a strong case, that it Constitutionally wasn't a tax.
Today, I think I can answer the second question.
This issue is discussed by Chief Justice Roberts on page 11 of his opinion (17 of the pdf)
It seems the answer to why this is not a tax for the purposes of the Anti-Injunction Act but is a tax for Constitutional Purposes is that the Anti-Injunction Act was written by Congress. So it applies only to things that Congress thinks is a tax.
It would be like if you and I had different definitions for the same thing, say a computer. Then I said I will buy you a computer. Do you expect what you consider a computer, or do you expect that I give you my version of a computer.
Since Congress passed the Anti-Injunction Act, and said taxes must be paid before they can be challenged. Then they wrote the ACA which calls it a "penalty," so the Anti-Injunction Act doesn't apply to it. I'll try to think of an analogy to make this clear.
Thursday, June 28, 2012
Yay Federalism!
Sarah Kliff reports that if the Individual Mandate is struck down, California is going to move forward on its own with a single-payer system.
Although, I personally don't think this is the way to go, I couldn't be happier that California has the opportunity to craft a health care system that works for them and doesn't have to follow the rules that were reached by compromise between all the competing interests and philosophies of the entire nation.
Although, I personally don't think this is the way to go, I couldn't be happier that California has the opportunity to craft a health care system that works for them and doesn't have to follow the rules that were reached by compromise between all the competing interests and philosophies of the entire nation.
Wednesday, June 27, 2012
Lives Must Be Saved
Families USA has recently suggested that invalidating the ACA will leave millions more uninsured which will result in more deaths. Therefore, we should make sure that these people stay insured. Of course, this isn't enough. Even with the ACA, millions will remain uninsured. That will result in even more deaths and can't be tolerated. Obviously, an individual mandate isn't enough to keep these people insured and save their lives. We must double-down on this insurance to make sure everyone can live an insured, healthy life.
With the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan winding down, we'll soon have soldiers without much to do. I propose we create some units that will be sent to force the uninsured to purchase insurance. The penalty for not having insurance in the ACA is clearly too weak. Think of all the lives that could be saved by intimidating these at-risk citizens with guns and violence.
To save even more lives, we should seriously consider curtailing people's traveling rights. Tens of thousands of people die each year in car accidents. Perhaps we should institute a national 10 mph speed limit on all roads or restrict driving all together.
With the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan winding down, we'll soon have soldiers without much to do. I propose we create some units that will be sent to force the uninsured to purchase insurance. The penalty for not having insurance in the ACA is clearly too weak. Think of all the lives that could be saved by intimidating these at-risk citizens with guns and violence.
To save even more lives, we should seriously consider curtailing people's traveling rights. Tens of thousands of people die each year in car accidents. Perhaps we should institute a national 10 mph speed limit on all roads or restrict driving all together.
Overturning Precedents
Ezra Klein interviews James Simon
Here's what Simon says on invalidating the individual mandate
He's talking about overturning Wickard v. Filburn. The case on which the modern interpretation of the commerce clause is based. What he conveniently forgets is that Wickard v. Filburn itself overturned 150 years of precedent by expanding the ability of the Federal government so that the New Deal would be possible, along with Medicare, Social Security, etc.--the modern welfare state.
Notice also how in his responses, conservative justices are always described as ideaological and liberals justices are just liberal.
Finally, in the final question, Ezra Klein worries about how the Supreme Court decided the 2000 election and then Bush went on to appoint two justices. As I recall, both justices were appointed in his second term, which was not decided by the courts in any way. Did Bush win an 8-year term in 2000 that I didn't know about?
Here's what Simon says on invalidating the individual mandate
But then the question comes, once you get five votes, do you simply uproot 75 years of constitutional precedent? If you do that, you’re not showing judicial restraint. You’re a very, very activist court. And then the court makes itself an issue in any political campaign. If a doctrine as important as the Commerce Clause doctrine can be reversed by a single vote or even two votes, without much attention to precedent, then the court becomes another political branch of the government.
He's talking about overturning Wickard v. Filburn. The case on which the modern interpretation of the commerce clause is based. What he conveniently forgets is that Wickard v. Filburn itself overturned 150 years of precedent by expanding the ability of the Federal government so that the New Deal would be possible, along with Medicare, Social Security, etc.--the modern welfare state.
Notice also how in his responses, conservative justices are always described as ideaological and liberals justices are just liberal.
Finally, in the final question, Ezra Klein worries about how the Supreme Court decided the 2000 election and then Bush went on to appoint two justices. As I recall, both justices were appointed in his second term, which was not decided by the courts in any way. Did Bush win an 8-year term in 2000 that I didn't know about?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)